Cricut: The $236 Million Disconnect
Cricut is not a broken company. With over $236 million in cash, zero debt, nine consecutive years of profitability, and more than 5.9 million active users, Cricut by every financial measure is a solid business. But solid financials do not tell the whole story. Right now, Cricut is navigating a dual challenge — a stock market that has lost confidence in its growth trajectory and a creator community that is feeling increasingly disconnected from the direction the brand is taking. The question worth asking is not whether the company is failing. The question is what exactly is Cricut doing, and why?
Before the pandemic Cricut had already built a loyal and established maker community around a core lineup of machines. The Cricut Explore series brought precision cutting to the home crafter. The Cricut Maker, released in 2017, was a genuine breakthrough, a machine that could cut fabric, wood, and a wide range of materials using an adaptive tool system that set it apart from anything else in the consumer craft space. These were machines that built the brand's reputation and gave makers a real reason to invest in the ecosystem.
Then came 2020. With people at home and looking for creative outlets the demand for Cricut machines surged. The Cricut Joy, launched in March of that year, expanded the brand's reach to an entirely new audience, casual makers, apartment dwellers, and people who had never previously considered a cutting machine. Cricut Access subscriptions grew. Revenue climbed to a peak of $1.3 billion. When the company went public in March 2021 at $20 a share the stock quickly rose to over $40. It was the high-water mark.
However, what followed has been a steady and telling decline. As the world reopened and the crafting boom cooled, Cricut responded with a high volume of new releases, two versions of the Maker series, multiple Explore iterations, the Mug Press, the Hat Press, the Autopress, the Venture, the Joy Xtra, the EasyPress SE, and most recently the Joy 2 and Explore 5. On the software side the company introduced Smart Materials, expanded Cricut Access, launched a DTF transfer service, overhauled the Design Space interface, and rolled out an AI Project Designer. Some of these landed. Many did not. The Autopress, priced near $1,000, missed the professional market it was targeting. The Venture entered a commercial cutting space already dominated by brands offering open software compatibility that Design Space could not match. The Cricut Bright 360 lamp asked makers to spend upward of $150 on a fixture with non-replaceable LED bulbs, a product the community quickly identified as overpriced when comparable lamps were available elsewhere for far less. The 2026 Design Space interface overhaul, which reorganized core tools into pop-out side panels, added friction for experienced makers who relied on muscle memory, the opposite of what a workflow update should accomplish.
Through all of this activity the results have remained discouraging. The active user count has stayed essentially flat, hardware revenue declined nearly 10% in the first quarter of 2026, and the stock has continued its downward drift from a peak of over $40 to its current range of around $4 a share. Major analysts at Goldman Sachs and Barclays have assigned Strong Sell and Underweight ratings, and in early 2026 company insiders sold over 1,800% more shares than they purchased. Taken together these signals paint a consistent picture. Neither Wall Street nor the maker community appears to be buying the story Cricut is currently telling.
Since hardware sales have flattened Cricut has shifted its focus toward growing platform revenue. The AI suite, the AI Project Designer, and the expanded Cricut Access subscription are designed to deepen engagement with existing users and convert those who have not yet moved to a paid subscription into monthly subscribers. Of the 5.9 million active users the company reports, just over 3 million are currently paid subscribers, leaving a meaningful gap the company is working to close. The strategy is understandable, but it keeps Cricut focused on the community it already has. Building AI features on top of a software experience that still carries foundational limitations raises a genuine question about whether the investment is addressing the right problem.
What is less visible in this strategy is any meaningful pursuit of communities that sit just beyond Cricut's current reach. One such community is the travel and tourism market, a growing segment of creative individuals who carry their maker instincts with them wherever they go. Travelers are crafters too. People who cruise, who stay in hotels, who take creative retreats carry their creativity with them and represent a community the brand has does not appear to have formally engaged.
The travel and tourism industry is already demonstrating that arts and crafts are a valued part of the travel experience. Carnival Cruise Line partnered with Michaels to bring craft programming to its entire fleet. Royal Caribbean has built dedicated permanent creative spaces on its Quantum class ships, staffed by professional instructors offering hands on maker workshops. Celebrity Cruises operates a fully functioning glassblowing studio at sea, one of the most ambitious creative offerings in the cruise industry. Independent craft cruise operators hosting specialized scrapbooking and stamping retreats on major cruise lines are sold out through 2026. The appetite is real and it is growing.
If this territory has not yet been explored it is worth serious consideration. Dedicated craft rooms on cruise ships equipped with Cricut machines where travelers can make custom door magnets, vacation keepsakes, and personalized gear as part of their experience. Hotels and resorts adding Cricut machines to their business centers or creating maker spaces for guests. Cricut sponsored crafting classes offered as part of travel itineraries. These are not far-fetched ideas. They are natural extensions of what the brand already does, applied to a community that is already spending, already creating, and already looking for exactly this kind of experience.
When the same approach keeps producing the same results, the most innovative move is to look somewhere entirely new. For Cricut, that doesn't mean building walls around a saturated market; it means looking up from the craft room and following its community where they actually go. And right now? They are traveling.
—————
* This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no cost to you. *
